It's completely one dimensional and expressionless.
It's about opinion, there's a subject included already, witch isn't the case with a typical general purpose smilie

Sorry Nestor, we differ regarding (music) taste and humor I'm afraid, but that's eh...taste

in case your monitor shows different.
Sure, there are plenty of those kind of smilies like this

But aren't we basicly talking about basic forum smilies here?
We need a well restricted list of the usual smilies, and both the old and new ones offer exactly those.
We just have to decide which ones, and I would say, just choose the old list.
They offer the same emotions like the new ones but are much better.
(Will come back on the other type of smilies Nestor).
Old members will remember my fascination with smilies.
I'm definitely oversensible regarding smilies.
If you check out http://www.mysmilies.com/?cat=happy and
related pages, you'll find a crazy bunch of great icons.
I searched for other smilie sites in the past, and I never found anything better.
Eighter the smilies weren't funny or esthetically attractive, or the site offered besides others exactly the same ones as in the link above.
Don't let me f.i. think of the MSN smilies, they are mostly ugly.
About other more specific 'smilies', as this is endless it's useless to think you can get a nice basic collection together.
Everyone who is capable to make nice own smilies is also capable to put them on a server to use them at wish.
If anyone doesn't like one of those, bad luck then, you're still free to use them!
That's what I think about the subject















