20 greatest synths of all time...

A place to talk about whatever Scope music/gear related stuff you want.

Moderators: valis, garyb

H-Rave
Posts: 569
Joined: Sat Apr 16, 2005 4:00 pm
Location: Toulouse, France
Contact:

Post by H-Rave »

Nice, the presenter looks like a synth perve.
:lol:
Core2Quad Q9400 2.66Ghz, Asus P5Q EPU,Radeon HD4350 4Gb Ram,320Gb 7200Rpm,Windows 7 Pro 32 bit,Cubase 4+5,NI Komplete 5+6, Scope 5 - Mix&Master - Synth&Sampler,Pulsar II Classic - PulsarII XTC,.Core2duo 3.00Ghz.Presonus Firestudio Tascam FW1884
iskra
Posts: 81
Joined: Sat May 03, 2003 4:00 pm

Post by iskra »

I'd agree with that guess, at two i'd guess tb303
CarvinGuitarFreak
Posts: 130
Joined: Wed Sep 20, 2006 4:00 pm

Post by CarvinGuitarFreak »

Nice one... :D
dawman
Posts: 14368
Joined: Sun Jul 24, 2005 4:00 pm
Location: PROJECT WINDOW

Post by dawman »

I tend to believe this person was trying to run 4 Governor, or something.

He obviously hasn't spent much time on Oberheims as the Matrix 12 / XPander combo makes the OB8 sound thin, even if it was A / B 'd through a Pignose amplifier !

I totally agree on the Prophet V, DX7, and the 2600. But the EMU Proteus ? @$#%!^&^@( ??? Please, that's a PCM sack of shit. Hey 500 presets !! Yeah, 500 weak ones. Yeah but 40 ZPlane filters that sound like EQ's, not filters. It's outputs ooze dairy products. I love the taste of American cheese on a burger, but it is a far cry from France, or even Wisconsin. Sheeezuss.

His conclusions are obviously drawn from sales figures, or his experiences visiting music stores, which rarely had demos of the FAT BASTARDS. Look @ Hanz Zimmers racks and you'll notice the Oberheim OBM-x w/ 12 voices. It came stock w/ 2, and each additional pair of voices was 600 USD, i.e., 300 USD per voice. It was T.Oberheims design, w/ Don Buchla adding a Moog style filter and extra routing options. Where is the Moog Series 100 Modular? And please, I bought a CS-80 and it was the biggest dissapoinment in my life. 6800 USD back in late '70's. I paid on it for 3 years to HFC, as my bank wouldn't spot me more than 5 large.

When he plays JB's Solaris, he probably would say,...well it sounds O.K., but where's the factory brass patch.

I wish the Gods from that era would descend upon him w/ their FAT BASTARDS, and show him what he obviously missed while he was breast feeding !!

Nope, I'm, quite sure he has a Chihuahua as his hunting DAWg.
hubird

Post by hubird »

you're right if you ask me.
So much possible these days, at so much quality level.

the TB 303 was d*mn popular in electronic music, I bought one 2ndh. for 100,- EU, long before dance music evolved, and sold it for 400,- EU, years after dance got usual (and I knew the price was cheap) :-D
It's hard to bring an order in the classic synths, it heavily depends on your musical preferences and personal history.
The 303 won't appeal to all synth lovers, ELP lovers won't care that much about the kwerqi 303 sound, and dance lovers don't like the huge synth layers so much.

Yet, it's remarkable that it was the most primitive synth ever which caused that revolution in making and experiencing music.
An ultimately simple machine that brought back -tho not on it's own- the ultimate dance factor, that was and is remarkable.

I tend to give historical impact the most important role regarding the order one can give to classic synths.

I then would say, number one is the Mellotron, tho not a synth but I don't care :-)
Before any synths got used in pop songs (I guess), there was Nights in white satin, aaaaahhaaaaaa :-D
Suddenly you didn't have to sound like a rock-band when being a rock-band...

After that, it took untill about 1987 (UK, 1989 Holland) before something really happened :-D
At least that was my experience, as after ten minutes on a small dance party I was sold :-)

So, quicksilver messenger service TB 303 is my number two, as it's the mother of (electronic) inventions, to stay in tune .
If you also count in the revolutionary impact Rebirth and Reason had in making music and the accessability of it, it's hardly possible to give that #1 position to another synth, tho I don't mind really :-)

I once bought me a 303 clone, soldered together with the original components etc., no sequencer tho, just sound-generating. in a perspex casing.
Worked perfect.
Untill I A-B'd the original with the copy, using the same pattern, the 303 internal, and for the clone the native sequencer...
There was a tremendous difference in groove, believe it or not.
The note's sound was actually perfectly identical, but the internal sequencer made the difference.
I then learnt something :-D
iskra
Posts: 81
Joined: Sat May 03, 2003 4:00 pm

Post by iskra »

tend to believe this person was trying to run 4 Governor, or something.
lol.... I think there was actually something on the site that the synths were voted on ( I have no idea by how many people or what their musical tastes)...but I guess some of the purpose of lists like this is to spark debates, which then generates a larger audience
There was a tremendous difference in groove, believe it or not.
The note's sound was actually perfectly identical, but the internal sequencer made the difference.
I then learnt something
I've never used a real tb303, but I've heard it said before that the trick was in the sequencer, I've started to learn in my own music that groove can add more to the sound, than the sound itself, if that makes any sense....there's probably a better way to put it
iskra
Posts: 81
Joined: Sat May 03, 2003 4:00 pm

Post by iskra »

tend to believe this person was trying to run 4 Governor, or something.
lol.... I think there was actually something on the site that the synths were voted on ( I have no idea by how many people or what their musical tastes)...but I guess some of the purpose of lists like this is to spark debates, which then generates a larger audience
There was a tremendous difference in groove, believe it or not.
The note's sound was actually perfectly identical, but the internal sequencer made the difference.
I then learnt something
I've never used a real tb303, but I've heard it said before that the trick was in the sequencer, I've started to learn in my own music that groove can add more to the sound, than the sound itself, if that makes any sense....there's probably a better way to put it
tgstgs
Posts: 526
Joined: Sun Jan 15, 2006 4:00 pm

Post by tgstgs »

@scope4live

as the picture shows one of viennas great artists i want to add that josef zawinul is an incredible performer equal on what intrument he uses;
he has a club here in vienna (birdland) were he himself sometimes perform;
a must see!!!!!!

sorry for being of topic!

good vibes from vienna
User avatar
Shroomz~>
Posts: 5669
Joined: Wed Feb 23, 2005 4:00 pm
Location: The Blue Shadows

Post by Shroomz~> »

It would be funny if they left out synths like the Elka Synthex, memory moog & Crumar Spirit in favour of the proteous, virus etc.

Another thing... How can the Juno-60 be higher in the list than the JP-8? This list can't be taken seriously :lol:
Liquid Len
Posts: 652
Joined: Tue Dec 09, 2003 4:00 pm
Location: Home By The Sea

Post by Liquid Len »

It's a vote-in thing, and apparently people think the Roland D-50 is a better synth than either of them.

As for the proteus being on or near that list, maybe it's just the gear they already have, and they needed some cognitive dissonance reduction.
dawman
Posts: 14368
Joined: Sun Jul 24, 2005 4:00 pm
Location: PROJECT WINDOW

Post by dawman »

Nope,....it's members are obviously are unworthy of battle.

I haven't seen Josef Zawinul play live for 20 years now. I am happy you have the chance of a lifetime to see first hand such a master perform. I would fly to Vienna to see that. That's how impressive of a live performer he is. I always think of Mozart, and Zawinul as true masters of Vienna.

I was doing my second recording in Miami @ Criteria w/ Mothers Finest, when Jaco and Josef had the " A " booth. I was in a successful band, but felt like a musical whore after hearing their tracks. Then they starting touring ( Weather Report ) Birdland was the first track off of the Heavy Weather Album. I was just starting to regain my ego that was destroyed as we opened for every big act out back then. But these public beatings I endured forced me to practice intensely, as I was determined that next years tour dates would be less embarrassing for me. I still thank God for those experiences I had as a young teen playing with all of those veterans. I wish I could convey the importance of continuos live performance to all of my Brothas' here. Jamming is great, but true improvements stem from live shows that never seem to stop. I never thought that I would be performing professionally live for 36 years now. I can't stop though, as it is all I know, with the exception of course of chugging vast quantities of Jaegermeister. It took away the pain of my humiliation back then, and I can't stop doing that either.

Let us do a thread of what we think are the greatest 20 synths of all time. Staring with the 60's, and the Beach Boys using a Theramin on Good Vibrations.

I think that was where another idol of mine got the phrase in his song 3rd Stone From The Sun,..............................................................................................So Unto You I Shall Split The Earth,...And You'll Never Hear Surf Music Again.

Jimi Hendrix Experience
User avatar
Me$$iah
Posts: 379
Joined: Sun Jul 03, 2005 4:00 pm
Contact:

Post by Me$$iah »

When I worked in the 'big studio' I used a proteus all the time..

It was such an easy way to compose....we had a huge rack full of synths, all being driven by cubase on an atari. But when songwriting instead of patching in a million units, it was much easier to just use the presets on the proteus, with the s1000 for loops etc.

When the track was finished, I could then spend time finding the perfect sounds using the other unitsI (loved the D-550 btw). Before sending them to the to the main desk and onto tape.

I think the proteus is there for that reason.

Tho #1 is gonna be the moog, and we all know it. And I agree that the 303 will be #2.

My personal fave..... I dont know..... the stylophone...maybe ..... or the theramin (I love the old sci-fi movie sounds) .......I also love the Hammond organ..tho that aint a synth, I just wanted to mention it

I did enjoy the JD-800 and the D-550(D-50 in a rack).. so I guess they are my #1s.... but then what do I know.... Im a guitarist, that dabbles with these technobeasts.....
mike.kennedy
Posts: 39
Joined: Fri Apr 08, 2005 4:00 pm
Location: Monmouth, Wales
Contact:

Post by mike.kennedy »

Can I put in a word for the EMS synths - Synthi100 and VCS3?

Mike
dawman
Posts: 14368
Joined: Sun Jul 24, 2005 4:00 pm
Location: PROJECT WINDOW

Post by dawman »

Indeed,
And I'll provide the picture. The year I graduated from high school, this one ( synthi 100 ) was set up at a local music store. I knew that the Who, and Pink Floyd had used Electronic Music Studio synths in their '72 tours which I was fortumate enough to see. They were ahead of the times in style, and performance features, i.e. the peg style was so convenient, and believe me at a gig back then for a keyboard guy to try and patch up the ARP2600, was a real nightmare. But after hearing Riding The Storm by REO Speedwagon, I had to have one regardless of the gymnastics needed when switching patch cords.
I second the EMS series that started back in '69, when the births of all things we emulate started.
dawman
Posts: 14368
Joined: Sun Jul 24, 2005 4:00 pm
Location: PROJECT WINDOW

Post by dawman »

I would like to acknowledge the excellent quality and build of the only company that still builds polyphonic analog beasts. Studio Electronics. I have used their SE series synths for quite a while now, and believe that their new Code synth will remain the king of FAT in the world of analog.

The addition of sinewave generators on each voice has to sound incredible. I will let you know, as my M780 buddy has the Omega, and is now buying this one. That DIRTY BASTARD. I shall punish him w/ Solaris this fall.
User avatar
hifiboom
Posts: 2057
Joined: Thu Aug 03, 2006 4:00 pm
Location: Germany, Munich
Contact:

Post by hifiboom »

nice beast

Image
User avatar
Hysteric
Posts: 115
Joined: Sat Jul 08, 2006 4:00 pm
Location: South Australia

Post by Hysteric »

for me even though it may not be the Best synth ever created is the Octave Kitten. My reason is fairly simple, I could afford it in London years ago and the sound blew my mind away. To put it simply, it got me into synths and I've always had a soft spot and with good reason I think, this synth was great fun. :)
mike.kennedy
Posts: 39
Joined: Fri Apr 08, 2005 4:00 pm
Location: Monmouth, Wales
Contact:

Post by mike.kennedy »

Thanks for the EMS pics Jimmy.

I was lucky enough to get a place on the postgrad Diploma in Electronic Sound course at UC Cardiff back in 1978 where they had a Synthi 100 and a few other EMSs (VCS3s and Synthi A - the synth in a suitcase).

As I'm not a keyboard player, these were great instruments because you didn't need a keyboard to get a sound out of them - in fact the VCS3 defaulted to no keyboard. In spite of this the VCS3 (as it was portable - Synthi 100 definitely not) was used by a number of Brit bands in the late 60s / early 70s - notably Pink Floyd, Hawkwind, Led Zep and Roxy Music. At the time I was most disappointed to find that the (affordable) Jap synths had no patchboard!

Anyway, I was fortunate to have regular access to these systems for nearly a year and can vouch for their sonic qualities and useability. One of the guys in the department had (convincingly) reproduced "Knights in White Satin" - complete with guitar fret noses - entirely using multitracked Synthi 100. I wonder what has happened to that recording - and all the EMS kit that was owned by UCC!

VST emulation of the Synthi A is available here: http://www.emsrehberg.de/SYNTHI__s/SYNT ... lugin.html - although it's a little expensive at 350 euros! No idea what it's like as I haven't tried the demo yet.

Cheers,

Mike
User avatar
hifiboom
Posts: 2057
Joined: Thu Aug 03, 2006 4:00 pm
Location: Germany, Munich
Contact:

Post by hifiboom »

I`ve tried the demo. And its quite funny and has a "good sound" although I think its not the same as the real one soundwise...


but the matrix is very cool..... something like this could be nice for the CW modular too. :)
Post Reply